a90skid.com
  • Home
  • News
    • Nintendo
    • PlayStation
    • Xbox
  • Reviews
  • Opinion
A 90s Kid
  • Home
  • News
    • Nintendo
    • PlayStation
    • Xbox
  • Reviews
  • Opinion
SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

For the latest video game news, reviews and more subscribe to our weekly newsletter.

  • Industry
  • Opinion

The problem with 8/10 review scores

  • August 7, 2017
  • Mathew Falvai

Everywhere I look I see 8/10. It’s the single most boring and easiest score to give. A 9 is essential and special, a 7 has issues, and anything 6 and below will be avoided like the plague. I score games out of 5 (5 is excellent, 4 is strong, 3 is for fans of the genre, 2 is mediocre, and 1 is a disaster). I used to score out of three! (buy it, try it, avoid it). I currently don’t see a use for a ten point scale and find the 8.9 etc on some sites a ludicrously complex way to give a slightly different 8.

Obviously some games should be 8s. Our own Matthew Owen gave Tacoma an 8.5 and I take from his review that the experience was splendid, but he wanted more of it. That sounds better than a 7 on creative merit, but lacking enough content to earn that solid 9 or *gasp, higher! (Love ya Matt).

And yes I realize the hilarious irony that my 4/5s will be converted to 8/10 by metacritic.

Here are some games that received an 8 (or up to 8.9) on the big two gaming sites:

  • Tacoma
  • Overcooked
  • Splatoon 2
  • FFXII zodiac age
  • Diablo 3
  • Breath of the wild Master Trials
  • Crash n.sane
  • Ever Oasis
  • Arms
  • ESO morrowind
  • Walking Dead New Frontier from the Gallows
  • Sundered
  • Splatoon 2 (both sites)
  • FFXIV stormblod
  • Cities Skyline Mass Transit
  • Tekken 7
  • Endless Space 2
  • COD Black Ops 3 Zombies Chronicles
  • Strafe
  • Little nightmares
  • DQ heroes 2
  • Puyo Puyo Tetris
  • Warhammer 40k Dawn of War 2
  • Mr shifty
  • MLB the show 17
  • For Honor
  • Sniper elite 4
  • Resident evil 7
  • Yakuza 0
  • Killing floor 2
  • I Expect You to Die
  • Orwell
  • FFXV
  • Watch Dogs 2
  • Hitman
  • Overcooked
  • DQ builders
  • Dishonored 2
  • Tyranny

Reviews are opinions of course, although I’d hardly call an 8 an opinion. In my opinion there is a huge variety of quality on this list.

Dishonored is a stunning example of stealth action. It has a weak narrative in between levels, but when a game is this good at environmental storytelling, you don’t need anything more but simple cutscenes. The excellent gameplay is a nothing short of a 9. I gave it a 3/3 ‘buy it’ in my review here.

Hitman: Giant Bomb’s GOTY, a stealth game that is actually fun to get caught, and a game that makes episodic releases and DLC elusive targets seem like the greatest ideas in gaming, should be saved from the bland mediocrity of an 8. It’s a beautiful unique flower that needs to shine brighter than the pack of every other AAA game with enough production values to garner that same old score.

Mr Shifty has a few great ideas but is not great itself. It gets bogged down in repetition and lacks the compelling style and narrative of its inspiration: Hotline Miami. I gave it a 3/5 as the limited scope is fun while it lasts, and maybe someone will recognize it as being right up their alley.

Crash N.Sane Trilogy and FFXV are games that look great but have enough flaws that they shouldn’t be in the same category as Splatoon 2, Yakuza 0, or Overcooked to name a few. If a gamer had enough money to purchase just one of the games I mentioned, I would hate for them to think FFXV is as good as Overcooked. You can argue about apples to oranges or subjectivity but FFXV is obviously flawed while Overcooked is a taught masterpiece.

What’s my point?

I can’t tell other people how to review games, and an 8 is a score that easily describes just about every game in existence (E.T, cultural landmark with flaws, 8/10).

But an 8 doesn’t tell me enough about a game to lump so many titles into one designation (no matter how many damn decimal points you have). A 9 or 10 is special, a 7 has flaws, an 8 is the equation you get when adding up review scores with a math formula when they should be scored on feeling.

A beautiful, polished, but soul-less AAA game shouldn’t get an 8, it should get knocked down to a 7 or less for not being FUN. We should also reward games that are unique and FUN with a recognizably great 9 or 10 even if they lack story or some other ticky-tack demerits that knock it down to an 8.

Perhaps the problem is that game development has reached a high enough technical level that anything below an 8 for most projects is an insult. But I play games to have fun, not admire anti-aliasing.

My ultimate point might be that review scores are meaningless without context, and you should read the content before skipping to the bottom for the shiny number, but even I can’t help myself from doing that. Heck, I wrote 700+ words on review scores, so they must be meaningful to me.

Criticize my thoughts below, but please don’t give them an 8/10.

Total
1
Shares
Share 1
Tweet 0
Pin it 0
Related Topics
  • games
  • gamespot
  • ign
  • review scores
  • video games
Mathew Falvai
Mathew Falvai

Mathew is a huge fan of Space, Strategy, and Shadowrun (Genesis version is #1). When it comes to games and films, he’d much rather experience a 10/10 classic from yesteryear than a 6/10 modern blandfest. He does feel we’re living in a gaming golden age with the power of indie developers at an all-time high, but wishes AAA publishers would take more risks. Mat believes it’s only a matter of time before the pendulum swings the other way and new ideas take their rightful place above reboots.

You May Also Like
Zelda Ocarina of Time Glitch at AGDQ 2021
View Post
  • 6 min
  • AGDQ 2021
  • Opinion

The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Seven

  • Matthew Owen
  • January 12, 2021
Super Mario 64 Blindfolded at AGDQ 2021
View Post
  • 5 min
  • AGDQ 2021
  • Opinion

The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Six

  • Matthew Owen
  • January 9, 2021
Zelda Wand of Gamelon AGDQ 2021
View Post
  • 5 min
  • AGDQ 2021
  • Opinion

The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Five

  • Matthew Owen
  • January 8, 2021
Spyro 3 Skateboarding
View Post
  • 6 min
  • AGDQ 2021
  • Opinion

The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Four

  • Matthew Owen
  • January 7, 2021
Cuphead at AGDQ 2021
View Post
  • 7 min
  • AGDQ 2021
  • Opinion

The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Three

  • Matthew Owen
  • January 6, 2021
Sonic 1 World Record at AGDQ 2021
View Post
  • 5 min
  • AGDQ 2021
  • Opinion

The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Two

  • Matthew Owen
  • January 5, 2021
Donkey Kong Country AGDQ 2021
View Post
  • 3 min
  • AGDQ 2021
  • Opinion

The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day One

  • Matthew Owen
  • January 4, 2021
AGDQ 2019 Banner
View Post
  • 9 min
  • News
  • Opinion

The AGDQ 2021 Schedule is Live, Here’s What to Watch

  • Matthew Owen
  • December 30, 2020

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

TRENDING
  • Donkey Kong Country AGDQ 2021
    The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day One
  • Super Mario 64 Blindfolded at AGDQ 2021
    The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Six
  • Cuphead at AGDQ 2021
    The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Three
  • Spyro 3 Skateboarding
    The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Four
  • Black Ops Cold War Vietnam
    Call of Duty: Black Ops Cold War Review – A Satisfying Duty Done
Instagram
Celebrating the best game music of the decade in less than an hour on YouTube Facebook twitch dlive but not Instagram. 7 0
#gaming #gamingdaily #gamingmemes #morrowind #skyrim 6 0
#skyrim #morrowind #gaming #gamingmemes 8 0
#morrowind #skyrim #elderscrolls 8 2
#finalfantasy #nobuouematsu 7 0
#hyperlightdrifter streaming now. :) 7 0
When you typo links awakening and stumble into a very specific YouTube niche 6 0
Please check out our review of #MarvelsAvengers if you're interested! Many thanks to @msigaming_anz for letting us review the game on their powerful and sleek GE66 Raider. @intelanz is throwing you the game with any MSI laptop with a 9th or 10th Gen INTEL Core i5, i7, or i9 Processor H-Series (Australia and New Zealand) Link is in the bio! 10 0
Our review of #SeriousSam4 by @officialcroteam is live! Shout out to @msigaming_anz for letting us review the game on their super impressive GS75 Stealth gaming laptop (link in bio) 9 0
#itdobelikedat #belikedat 7 0
Streaming #ico in 10 minutes.  First time playing.  Also trying to just play with the obs monitor on my tv.  Anyone else do that ? 4 0
@ghostoftsushimathegame #gaming #memes #gamingmemesdaily 12 2
Follow
Author
Mathew Falvai
Mathew Falvai
Mathew is a huge fan of Space, Strategy, and Shadowrun (Genesis version is #1). When it…
View Posts

a90skid.com

18 User(s) Online Join Server

Subscribe

Subscribe now to our newsletter

Celebrating the best game music of the decade in less than an hour on YouTube Facebook twitch dlive but not Instagram. 7 0
#gaming #gamingdaily #gamingmemes #morrowind #skyrim 6 0
#skyrim #morrowind #gaming #gamingmemes 8 0
#morrowind #skyrim #elderscrolls 8 2
#finalfantasy #nobuouematsu 7 0
#hyperlightdrifter streaming now. :) 7 0
A90KID.COM

VIDEO GAMES COMMUNITY & ENTERTAINMENT

A 90s Kid is an active website and media channel, dedicated to providing you information and entertainment related to the video games industry

Navigation
  • Home
  • News
    • Nintendo
    • PlayStation
    • Xbox
  • Reviews
  • Opinion
Recent Articles
  • Scott Pilgrim vs. the World: The Game – Complete Edition Review January 22, 2021
  • The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Seven January 12, 2021
  • The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Six January 9, 2021
  • The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Five January 8, 2021
  • The Best Speedruns of AGDQ 2021 Day Four January 7, 2021
A 90s Kid
© 2021

Input your search keywords and press Enter.